JESSE'S GIRL LIQUID EYELINER

PRICE: $6.99
CRUELTY FREE?: Yes
WATER PROOF?: Yes
LAST ALL DAY WITHOUT SMUDGING?: Yes

If you're looking for a high quality liquid eyeliner that's affordable and cruelty free, this is one to consider. Of all the liquid eyeliners I've tried, this is my favorite. They have good pigmentation and last all day.  
It's often hard to find a black liquid eyeliner that's actually an opaque black, so finding this was really nice.

The tip of the eyeliner is really ideal. It's not too stiff, but also not super loose like the Girlactick eyeliner. Shape wise, it is very similar to the Kat Von D Tattoo liners.
These do allow for you to make really fine to thick lines and it does dry up fast which is nice because it prevents smudging.
The only bad thing about these is that they will dry out if you leave it open too long... but that happens with every eyeliner. 

These come in a variety of different colors including: Black, Blue, Blue Hawaii, Dark Brown, Violet, Snow White, and Olive

Of all the different colors available for this product, I have not tried Snow White or Violet. However, the rest of the colors were well worth it. Overall these are my personal favorite eyeliners and they're very comparable to the Kat Von D Tattoo/ Lightening Liners (Which take longer to dry down).